Orfeh and Andy Karl have had an impressively long run as one of Broadway’s best couples. 

Although they met while doing the Broadway production of Saturday Night Fever, their irrepressible chemistry became the stuff of legend when they co-starred in Legally Blonde, which garnered Orfeh a Tony nomination. 

Karl earned his own Tony nods for Rocky, On the Twentieth Century, and Groundhog Day (for which he received an Olivier Award). Most recently, they were seen starring together in Pretty Woman as Kit De Luca and Edward Lewis.